A few days ago, someone in our business group asked what the person defined a ‘philosophical’ question: how long before an AI ‘brain’ is inserted in a ‘human’ body.
To me, that is not a philosophical question by a question born from misinformation and fear.
I believe that ‘a priori’ fear stems from ignorance and since the group chat did not really allow me to explore the subject in a coherent way, I promised to sum up my views in a more logical sequence.
Let me start by saying that I am no way in possession of a functioning crystal ball nor am I an expert in robotics : what I wish to summarise here is what I believe at this moment in time, with the hope that someone without ‘a priori’ fears and more knowledge of the subject matter can help move society forward, not backwards.
Allow me to start from two literary refences, The Bicentennial Man (I quote from my copy of The Complete Robot, Harper Collins,1995) and The Elderon Chronicles by Tarah Benner (2018-2020 available online).
Whilst there have been many books and films about the topic of the ‘relationship’ between humans and androids, I feel the Asimov’s work is still what explain the intrinsic impossibility of a ‘sentient’ android for the layman. The choice of Benner’s work is dictated by her ability to insert the problem in a not-so-distant future now: the colonisation of space.
Towards the end of The Bicentennial Man novel, we read Andrew say: If it brings me humanity, that will be worth it. If it doesn’t, it will bring an end to striving and that will be worth it, too. And just a few lines before the end of the story, we read: Andrew’s thoughts were slowly fading…Desperately he seized at them. Man! He was a man! He wanted that to be his last thought. He wanted to dissolve -die- with that.
My taking from The Elderon Chronicles , is that in a (possible?) future where androids have become a normal sight in our society, their ability to eventually put the word ’end’ to humanity as a logical consequence of assessing our intrinsic ‘imperfection’ can only be decided by a human.
Hence my conviction that there is no ‘I’ in robotics and (whether it would legally and scientifically be at all possible in the future) we can safely assume that inserting human consciousness in a silicon body will necessarily bring about its demise. The opposite, the insertion of an AI knowledge in the human body and its consequences was explored in Frontline (Book 4 of Spinward Fringe Broadcast by Randolph Lalonde,2009, again availabe online). Up to you to read Lalonde’s conclusions, if interested, but again the aim of the experiment was to ‘save’ a knowledge considered too powerful from an AI into a new biological body. In this case you need to suspend ‘your disbelief’ to be able to enter in the novel logic.
Looking at the problem from my own angle, I see no way that I could have a personal humanoid making me tea any time soon nor an AI is writing this for me…. let’s tell Alexa to put the kettle on instead…
So Long!